Complete — semantic phase identity adopted and APG19 reconciled.
Phase ID: APG19A
APG19A accepts APG19’s substantive partial outcome: ADR 0014, separate Bash, Bats, Zsh, and reserved ZUnit ownership, three provisional retained profiles, the ZUnit source/version deferral, calibrated warning bands, combined-signal escalation, semantic Red stops, read-only dogfood, twelve-skill development integration, six-skill public v0.2 lifecycle, unchanged maturity, and deferred application smoke.
ADR 0015 and the phase and record identity guide adopt:
docs/adr/ and exit sequences unique within
docs/status/, with no cross-comparison;The standard-library apg-check-record-identity command validates indexed exit
existence and exact coverage, independent sequence uniqueness, case-insensitive
phase uniqueness, canonical spelling, new-record agreement, phase allocation
expectations, and independently computed next values. The public-release gate
includes the command, helper, integration tests, help, compilation, and
configured validation without changing schema version 1 or the six critical
v0.2 skills.
APG19 tracked evidence now identifies dogfood and candidate cases with stable phase-local IDs instead of content digests. bats-core v1.13.0, Zsh 5.9.2, and ZUnit v0.8.2 replace source commits where semantic releases exist. The dated unreleased ZUnit observation uses a phase-local source ID, public locator, and explicit mutability limitation.
Current provenance and the skill catalog replace unversioned third-party Git pins with phase-local source IDs, public locators, inspection dates, and stated revision limitations. Root and private instructions, project governance, coordination, authoring, roadmap, catalog, integration, release, evaluation, and status owners now implement the semantic identity and precommit policy.
The focused scan covers changed tracked files and current identity owners. It does not impose a repository-wide hexadecimal ban that would confuse licenses, fixtures, historical raw evidence, or report-owned objects with durable semantic references.
Bash threshold, quoting, expansion, pipeline, set -e, pipefail, trap,
temporary-resource, dynamic-execution, destructive-target, legacy-fix, and
process-owner boundaries were accepted without correction. The Bash leaf
remains byte-identical to APG19.
Zsh option locality, emulation, arrays, splitting, expansion, globbing, startup, autoload, hooks, ZLE, completion, module, dynamic-source, destructive-glob, legacy-fix, and process-owner boundaries were accepted without correction. The Zsh leaf remains byte-identical to APG19.
ZUnit v0.8.2 remains the latest canonical release, the later default-branch observation remains documentation-only, and historical CI still ends at Zsh 5.3.1. The ADR 0014 re-entry condition remains truthful and no ZUnit skill is implemented.
The Bats audit reproduced one material fallback-count defect. bats-core v1.13.0
supports a comment function form such as function case_name { #@test; the
APG19 instruction to count @test declarations after excluding comments could
omit runner-recognized tests and understate Yellow, Orange, or Red bands. One
forward correction now counts runner-recognized native and supported comment
forms, excludes incidental strings, comments, heredocs, fixtures, and static
samples, and forbids evaluating a target Bats file merely to count without
authority. All thresholds and other Bats semantics remain unchanged.
The corrected Bats contract was reapplied to the shared structural, domain-specific, exact-boundary, coupled-signal, and seven-category read-only dogfood evidence. The supported comment-form boundary now receives the same test-count band as the runner. No second correction was required.
Private development remains twelve canonical skills and projections: six stable process skills and six provisional v0.3 skills. The router remains provisional with eleven routable non-router entries. Project, user, and public release lifecycle defaults remain exactly the six stable v0.2 skills under schema version 1. Public v0.2.0 and the active integration are unchanged.
The identity command, helper, tests, ADR, guide, evaluation, and exit are exact public-surface additions for a future authorized release; APG19A performs no publication. The Bats correction changes one existing provisional leaf without changing maturity, routing, catalog membership, projection shape, installer state, or release skill policy.
Failing-first evidence covered the Bats count wording and the absent identity command. Focused tests then passed for supported comment-form wording, independent ADR/exit namespaces, duplicate sequences, exact exit indexing, case-insensitive phase uniqueness, canonical spelling, record-field agreement, new-record explicit phase fields, and phase allocation expectations.
The complete resulting tree passed the repository’s Bats, skill-library, record-identity, project, checker, release, and user unit/integration suites; development and fresh public-v0.2 checker text/JSON; Python compilation; applicable shell syntax; command help; Markdown and local-link review; privacy, mode, schema, current-state, identity, sequence, and whitespace checks. Fresh non-author policy, profile, integration, and complete-diff reviews accepted the resolved tree.
No root guidance was removed, no private skill was decommissioned, and no public, reference, RepoMap, active-integration, or dogfood source was mutated. No application smoke was run; APG23 and APG24 retain that responsibility. No Go, Ruby, Nix, PostgreSQL, SQLite, ZUnit, or manager-prompt profile or skill was implemented in APG19A.
The maintainer’s two-phase assignment authorizes APG20 only after APG19A’s independent review, precommit record finalization, identity checks, commit, push, remote equality, and schema-valid managed reports all complete. No phase after APG20 is authorized.
APG22B later retains a provisional ZUnit profile only for exact ZUnit v0.8.2 with Zsh 5.9.2 in the tested environment. The exact Zsh 5.3.1 pair is unsupported. This subsequent result preserves APG19A’s semantic identity policy and historical reconciliation record.