agentic-praxis-grimoire

APG13 Six-Skill Post-Superpowers Stability Review Exit

Disposition

Complete — six skills promoted to stable

Authority and objective

The human maintainer authorized APG13 to accept APG12A, inventory and review each of the six current leaves, correct at most one demonstrated material defect per skill, promote passing catalog rows, validate the integrated private development state, and produce one private commit, push, and managed reports. The phase did not authorize a public candidate, publication, active integration change, external-repository mutation, Superpowers restoration, or APG14 work.

APG12A acceptance

APG12A is accepted as complete. Its exact public-lineage, strict later-base policy, disposable candidate/base validation, isolated environment, original fingerprint preservation, and genuinely read-only user check remain the accepted corrected distribution foundation. ADR 0009 and version-1 schemas remain unchanged.

Stable criteria and evidence matrix

ADR 0010 requires coherent ownership and triggers, preserved authority, proportional procedure, repeated positive use, separate representative non-triggers, edge or stop behavior, fresh completion evidence, safety and privacy, post-Superpowers suitability, maintenance and rollback, mechanical regression, and fresh non-author review.

The publication-excluded matrix classifies APG4-APG12A positive real use, textual scenarios, non-triggers, integration, mechanics, distribution, and historical corrections separately. It records correction history, independent reviews, privacy and authority findings, hashes, rollback owners, and evidence limitations for each leaf.

Individual dispositions

Skill	Frozen positive/non-trigger/edge result	Final review	Maturity
`composing-bounded-worker-assignments`	Bounded assignment / direct work / overlap or expansion stop	`accept-stable`	`stable`
`designing-significant-changes`	Consequential decision / accepted design / reversible assumption or reserved-decision stop	`accept-stable`	`stable`
`planning-repository-work`	Dependent units / one local action / invalidated-plan stop	`accept-stable`	`stable`
`implementing-with-test-discipline`	Proportional behavioral evidence / documentation-mechanical work / lifecycle-owned removal stop	`accept-stable`	`stable`
`debugging-systematically`	Hypothesis-driven record / expected red test / stale, unreproducible, or unauthorized stop	`accept-stable`	`stable`
`reviewing-and-verifying-repository-work`	Evidence-backed disposition / casual feedback / changed, stale, or missing-authority stop	`accept-stable`	`stable`

Every SKILL.md remains byte-identical to the APG12A baseline. No before/after hash differs and no correction-specific rerun was necessary. The complete regression supplies resulting-state evidence for all six.

Subsequent evidence-classification correction

APG14 corrected an APG13 record error: APG9 is a non-trigger, not positive use, for both implementing-with-test-discipline and debugging-systematically. Its bounded inspection, decommission, review, integration observation, smoke, and roadmap work did not constitute behavioral implementation or investigation of an unexplained defect. The corrected named phase inventories still satisfy the accepted stable criteria. No skill content, frozen result, final review, correction count, or stable disposition changes.

Catalog and current owners

All six catalog rows change from provisional to stable. Current README, bootstrap, project-model, provenance, roadmap, skill-maintenance, ADR, status, and legacy-ledger owners reflect APG13 completion where needed. Historical records retain contemporaneous provisional wording. LT21 and LT24 are implemented-by-APG13. APG14 is next and separately authorized.

Validation

frozen scenario families: 6 of 6 passed;
final non-author maturity reviews: 6 of 6 accept-stable;
checker unit: 15 of 15;
checker integration: 58 of 58, including one platform-conditioned skip;
release unit: 8 of 8;
release integration: 32 of 32;
user unit: 8 of 8;
user integration: 39 of 39, including one public-root-conditioned skip where applicable;
report-tool Bats families: 22 of 22;
project-skill integration: 28 of 28;
development and public v0.1.0 checker text and JSON: pass;
Python compilation, Bash syntax/help, Markdown, local links, public-to-private, confidentiality, ADR, exit, file mode, schema, skill/projection, and Git whitespace gates: pass; and
independent complete-diff review: accepted with no unresolved blocker or material finding.

Public and private artifacts

Public artifacts are ADR 0010, the APG13 evaluation, this exit, catalog maturity updates, and reconciled current owners. Publication-excluded evidence contains the exact historical matrix, frozen applications, worker and reviewer dispositions, correction/hash record, and integrated review.

External state and scope preservation

The public v0.1.0 and reference repositories, RepoMap checkout, active public-backed user integration, and retired-Superpowers state remain unchanged. APG13 adds no skill, support directory, dependency, plugin, registry, daemon, schema, public candidate, public tag, public push, publication, or active integration update.

Limitations

Stability does not prove automatic invocation, clean A/B superiority, production warranty, universal applicability, a fixed task or test count, or positive use in a second repository for every skill. Public v0.1.0 retains its historical provisional catalog until a separately authorized release replaces it.

Next authorization and external disposition requested

All six skills are stable; the APG13 maturity condition for APG14 is met. Requested external disposition:

Complete — six skills promoted to stable

APG14 remains separately authorized and has not started.

This site is open source. Improve this page.